The jury trial for a Galesburg man accused of killing his disabled fiancée is underway in Knox County.
57-year-old Gerald E. Fry Jr., is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the death of 49-year-old Tricia A. Nichols, who was disabled due to a stroke and could not walk.
Nichols was found unresponsive on the floor of the couple’s apartment at 191 N. Prairie St. on April 15, 2025.
Photos shared with the jury on the first day of the trial Monday showed Nichols’ face and neck darkly bruised, her eyes swollen shut, an injury to the back of her head, and bruising on her left arm and chest.
Her cause of death was blunt force trauma and manual strangulation.
Knox County State’s Attorney Ashley Worby and Assistant State’s Attorney Kim Norton are prosecuting the case.
They called multiple Galesburg police officers to the stand who had responded to the scene.
Illinois State Police Crime Scene Investigator Chris Dronzek also testified for the state.
Norton took Dronzek through dozens of photographs of the apartment building, the couple’s apartment, bloodstained pillows, a bloodstained stuffed elephant, and a dumpster behind the building, where officers found an open trash bag containing bloodstained cleaning wipes and pieces of hair.
Dronzek also opened several sealed evidence envelopes on the stand.
One envelope contained one of the bloodstained cleaning wipes.
Another envelope contained broken pieces of a glass Pyrex dish, which were found in the dumpster behind the building with strands of hair adhered to the glass.
Norton then got permission from Judge Andrew Doyle to pass the evidence bag among jurors so each of them could feel the weight of the glass.
Jurors heard Fry’s 911 call, where he claimed Nichols’ injuries were caused by falling down the stairs two days before her death and falling out of her wheelchair one day before her death.
They also watched a 35-minute interrogation video of Fry from the evening of April 15, where he continued to claim the injuries were due to Nichols falling.
Fry’s public defender, Scott Kamin, did not object to any evidence or any of the prosecution’s questioning on the first day of the trial, and he did not cross-examine most witnesses.
In his opening statement, Kamin said there were people with criminal records who lived near Fry and Nichols that police didn’t investigate.
Testimony will continue today. This morning, the jury will view a longer interrogation video of Fry that was conducted several days after the initial one.
Fry and Nichols had been in a relationship for eight years and had been engaged for five years at the time of her death.
Nichols suffered a stroke about a year and a half before her death. After the stroke, she relied on Fry for care.