Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Jury hears details of Nichols’ injuries, Fry’s meth use in Galesburg murder trial

Court news from Tri States Public Radio.

Gerald E. Fry Jr. used meth on the day his disabled fiancée was found unresponsive on the floor of their Galesburg apartment in the spring of last year, her eyes swollen shut and her face and neck covered in dark purple and red bruises.

That’s according to a lengthy interrogation video played for jurors during Fry’s murder trial Wednesday in Knox County.

The 57-year-old Fry is charged with two counts of murder in the death of 49-year-old Tricia Nichols on April 15, 2025. He’s accused of killing Nichols in their apartment at 191 N. Prairie St. because he no longer wanted to be her partner or caregiver.

In the video, Fry admits using meth but has maintained that Nichols’ extensive injuries were the result of accidental falls.

The two had been in a relationship for eight years and engaged for five at the time of Nichols’ death. Nichols, who suffered a stroke around a year and a half before her death, could not walk.

Also on Wednesday, Knox County State’s Attorney Ashley Worby called forensic pathologist Amanda Youmans to testify. Youmans conducted Nichols’ autopsy and determined she died of blunt force trauma and manual strangulation.

“The injuries were concentrated on her face and neck,” Youmans said.

Youmans testified that Nichols’ injuries could not have been caused by accidental falls. She said Nichols had multiple blunt force injuries to the face, neck, and scalp. She noted subgaleal hemorrhages when performing a scalp reflection.

“Upon incision, abundant blood exited her scalp,” Youmans said.

Nichols also had defensive wounds on her arms, a fractured larynx, and a broken hyoid bone.

Youmans testified the object used to inflict the injuries to her scalp was approximately three inches in diameter.

The state previously admitted two glass bowls into evidence that were found in a dumpster behind the apartment building. One was a three-quart Pyrex dish broken in pieces and the other was a smaller, intact glass bowl with a three-inch bottom.

The final witness for the state Wednesday was Kimberly Brown, a physician who was working in the emergency department at OSF St. Mary Medical Center in Galesburg in 2024.

Brown testified about treating Nichols for a panic attack in late September of 2024, saying Nichols went to the ER after a verbal altercation with Fry. She noted that Nichols was unkempt, disheveled, and had noticeable body odor.

When Nichols was about to be discharged, Brown witnessed another verbal altercation when Nichols called Fry to pick her up, and he refused to. Between the suspicion that Nichols was not receiving proper care at home and the verbal abuse, Brown intervened and worked to admit Nichols to the hospital for several days.

“She basically said she did not feel safe going home,” Brown said.

Another interrogation video played for jurors revealed Fry was a paid caregiver for Nichols through the Illinois Division of Rehabilitation Services. He admitted losing his paid position in the fall of 2024 after Nichols reported he threw a television at her.

Testimony continues today in the trial.

Jane Carlson is TSPR's regional reporter.