Tricia Nichols lived on the second floor of an apartment building that had no elevator.
After suffering a stroke in 2023, Nichols could not walk. She had trouble speaking. She slept in a wheelchair. She had to wear diapers that she couldn’t change by herself, and she needed help eating, drinking, and bathing.
Nichols died of blunt force trauma and manual strangulation on April 15, 2025, in the apartment at 191 N. Prairie St. in Galesburg she shared with her boyfriend of eight years — 57-year-old Gerald E. Fry Jr.
Fry was responsible for Nichols’ care as her partner and, for a while, as a paid personal assistant working for the Illinois Division of Rehabilitation Services.
He is now charged with Nichols’ murder.
In the third day of testimony in Fry’s jury trial, his nephew took the stand.
Austin Fry, 35, lived with Fry and Nichols in the Prairie Street apartment beginning in March of 2025, after experiencing homelessness.
Austin Fry said he moved into the only bedroom in the apartment while his uncle and Nichols slept in the living room. He said Nichols could not see clearly, had motor function difficulties, and never left the apartment.
After moving in, Austin Fry noticed arguments between Nichols and his uncle regarding her care, including having to change her diapers.
“He was very angry that he had to take care of her,” Austin said. “He was over it.”
While Austin Fry lived in the apartment, he began to change Nichols’ diapers.
“He told me he was tired of doing it,” Austin said.
Austin said Nichols typically was clothed only a diaper and t-shirt and that her hair was matted. He said he did see his uncle feed Nichols a few times.
“But that was it,” Austin said.
Austin was still living at the apartment when Nichols died. He testified that he saw her sleeping on the living room floor during daytime hours on April 15, 2025, but did not witness any injuries. He received a call from Gerald that evening while at a local video gaming parlor, saying Nichols was in need of help.
Initially, Austin believed Nichols’ injuries were caused by a fall down the stairs at the apartment building, and he remained living with his uncle. He testified that Gerald was no longer angry after Nichols died.
“He had this smile on his face I had never seen until she was gone,” Austin said.
Eric Littlefield of Allied Pest Control did notice Nichols’ injuries that afternoon when he was spraying for bugs in the building and entered the apartment.
“I saw a lady laying on the floor,” Littlefield said. “She turned and looked at me and I saw that her face was bruised.”
The extent of the bruising concerned Littlefield. Around that time, Littlefield said, a man in a red ball cap came into the apartment from one across the hall — and told him Nichols had fallen down the stairs and was refusing medical treatment.
Jurors also heard a 911 call from December 2024. Gerald Fry tells the dispatcher that he cannot take care of Nichols anymore.
“I’m done taking care of her,” he said. “She needs to go to a nursing home.”
Nichols can be heard in the background angrily moaning and yelling.
Then the dispatcher asks Fry who Nichols is to him.
“She’s nothing to me,” Fry says in return.
Others testifying Thursday were representatives from Stone-Hayes Center for Independent Living and the Division of Rehabilitation Services who had worked with Nichols and grew concerned about her safety.
Testimony is expected to conclude Friday morning, to be followed by closing arguments.
Knox County State’s Attorney Ashley Worby is seeking a natural life sentence for Fry.